Young children are frequently placed in institutional care throughout the world. This occurs despite
wide recognition that institutional care is associated with negative consequences for children’s development (Carter, 2005; Johnson, Browne and Hamilton-Giachritsis, 2006). For example, young
children in institutional care are more likely to suffer from poor health, physical underdevelopment and deterioration in brain growth, developmental delay and emotional attachment disorders. Consequently, these children have reduced intellectual, social and behavioural abilities compared with those growing up in a family home.

This paper provides an international summary of the extent and scale of young children living without parents in residential care ‘children’s homes’, and of the reasons they are there. This is
followed by an overview of the risk of harm to young children’s care and development after being
placed in institutional care, and considers core recommendations for policy and practice to
prevent harm and promote the rights of a child to grow up in a family environment (UNCRC, 1989).
To begin, a definition of what is meant by ‘institution or residential care home for children’ is presented to clarify the use of the term in this paper.

An institution or residential care home for children is defined as a group living arrangement for more
than ten children, without parents or surrogate parents, in which care is provided by a much smaller
number of paid adult carers. Typically in Europe this would be one carer to six children of a similar age during the day and fewer staff at night. Often the staff are inadequately trained and poorly supervised, making basic mistakes such as feeding a child (who should be able feed himself) on his back in a sleeping position (see plate 1).

Residential care implies an organised, routine and impersonal structure to the living arrangements for children (eg, all children sleep, eat and toilet at the same time) and a professional relationship, rather than parental relationship, between the adults and children. It is recognised that this definition would include children admitted to hospital, children in emergency care and those who attend boarding schools and summer camps. Therefore, children who live in an institution without a parent for more than three months are ‘institutionalised children’ and the focus of our concern.

Institutions or residential care homes for children are sometimes incorrectly referred to as ‘infant
homes’ or ‘orphanages’. The so-called ‘infant homes’ often provide a non-stimulating, clinical environment for toddlers and young children up to four years of age, and the vast majority (94 to 98%) of children in ‘orphanages’ have at least one living parent, often known to the authorities (Browne et al., 2005, 2006; Carter, 2005; Tobis, 2000). It is acknowledged that these figures do not refer to children in conflict or disaster zones, but even in these areas only a minority of children in institutions are orphans, with many of them being displaced and separated from a living parent or relative whose whereabouts may be unknown. Perhaps the increasing numbers of HIV orphans in sub-Saharan Africa are the only exception to this misnomer, although it has been reported that 59% of children from Zimbabwe living in institutions have at least one parent alive, and there is much anecdotal evidence that the majority of ‘HIV orphans’ in sub-Saharan Africa, whether in institutional care or otherwise, have at least one living parent.

Publication type
Author
Kevin Browne
Total pages
31
Countries this relates to
Language of materials
Projects and thematic pages

Childhub

You might like..

0
10
One of the biggest myths is that children in orphanages are there because they have no parents. This is not the case. Most are there because their parents simply can?t afford to feed, clothe and educate them. For governments and donors, placing…
0
51
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence has launched a free e-learning tool to help practitioners to implement its guidance on attachment in children who are adopted from care, in care or at high risk of going into care. Areas covered are…
0
357
More and more Bulgarian children are using the Internet, while the average age at which children discover the web for the first time is becoming lower. The Internet can be defined simply as a different setting in which the…
0
81
Based on the UK Safer Internet Center research young people are more likely to block someone behaving inappropriately than report them. This means that the scale of online abuse and harassment among children may be higher than the reported numbers…
0
105
According to data analysis results for BBC Radio 4’s File on 4 programme, the self-harm rate between children aged 9 to 12 has doubled over the past six years. The professor of psychiatry at the University of Oxford, Keith Hawton, considers in spite…
0
222
Few people associate the European Union with the protection of children’s rights. Most people think of it in terms of a single market and freedom of movement. But with greater economic integration comes massive social change. Unknown to many,…
0
9
During the not very distant totalitarian past in Czech Republic, it was quite common for people in wheel chairs to be cleared from the streets of Prague before the great Communist Party meeting. The legacy of the past, to consider any departure…
0
5
This research was conducted in the framework of “Mario project”:http://tdh-childprotection.org/projects/mario/description. In 2009, the project – funded by the Oak Foundation – started to better protect children on the move through the…
0
92
The project “Support to the implementation of National Standards of Care for Children in Residential Institutions in Albania” was under the framework of the cooperation between UNICEF and the Ministry of Labor Social Affair and Equal Opportunity.…
0
20
This is the third report in a three-part publication series by the NSPCC exploring the relationship between neglect in childhood and other forms of harm. This final contribution examines the link between experiencing neglect and engaging in harmful…
0
95
Eurochild is deeply concerned by the adoption of amendments to various laws by the Hungarian Parliament that contravene the rights of the child and stigmatise LGBTQI+ persons. We join the international community in condemning this law as it uses…
no
0
17
England: New study finds that children in care are more likely to have poorer mental health than the wider population during Covid-19 pandemic Background Impact of lockdowns and ensuing restrictions include a rise of poor mental health amongst…
no
0
153
An independent review of children’s social care in England has been published. The review is based on conversations with children and young people, which were organized in March 2021. The published reports include: a summary of…
0
52
This is an analysis of the key weaknesses identified in the most recent Inspectorate reports for the following 15 Prisons and Young Offenders Institutions that have children in custody. 
no
2
39
The Scottish government made a new plan according to which Sixteen and 17-year-olds in Scotland will not be placed in young offenders' institutions. The idea behind this plan is idea to fund "care-based alternatives" and shift the approach from "one…